ResolutionThat the City of Greater Sudbury accept the July 31, 2013 Variance Report dated October 2, 2013, from the Chief Financial Officer/Treasurer outlining the projected year end position.
The purpose of this report is to provide Council with a projection of the Municipality’s year-end position including potential year-end variances. The monitoring and reporting of variances has been conducted in accordance with the Operating Budget Policy and by-law.
For this July projection, departments reviewed all accounts under their areas of responsibility and provided projected year end values for each account. Based on this exercise, the data has been compiled and reviewed by Finance and a year-end deficit of approximately $0.6 Million (before a draw from Roads Winter Control Reserve Fund) has been projected. Staff have taken measures to mitigate this potential deficit and the corresponding draw from the Roads Winter Control Reserve Fund, by curtailing discretionary spending wherever possible.
This report will provide explanations regarding the potential year end position and explains variances in excess of $200,000 in a division or section.
The Reserves and Reserve Funds By-law allows certain operations to keep the surpluses generated in their respective areas, only if this does not put the municipality in a deficit position; these areas include Information Technology, Land Reclamation Services, Social Housing Services, Police Services and professional development. For 2013, these areas will not retain their respective surpluses, if the municipality is in a deficit position.
In accordance with the by-law any net over expenditure related to winter roads maintenance could be withdrawn from the Roads Winter Control Reserve Fund.
Attached is a chart that reflects the annual net budget, projection and variance.
In accordance with the Operating Budget Policy approved by Council, the following explanations relate to areas where a variance of greater than $200,000 is projected within a division or section:
1) Corporate Revenues
Staff has initially determined that a total potential negative variance of $500,000 may occur in supplementary tax revenue. The 2013 budgeted supplementary taxation revenue was decreased to $2.9 Million, which was the 2012 actual supplementary tax revenue received. The tax rolls received to date are reflecting less value than in previous years, which is resulting in the projected net shortfall. More information wil be available in the coming months.
In the area of tax write offs, it is still too early to project year-end positions as there are still some large appeals outstanding. However, it is anticipated that the allowance maybe sufficient to handle successful appeals undertaken by taxpayers.
2) Corporate Security and Court Services
Revenue is dependent on charges laid, decisions made in court and on the timing of collection of fines. As a result of recent fine announcements, this section is projecting to have revenues exceeding budget by $900,000 for the year.
3) Compliance and Enforcement
Lower than expected revenues from Lottery and Bingo Licences of $110,000, parking fines and fees of $80,000 (net of revenue sharing costs) and business licencing revenues of $30,000 have resulted in a projected net deficit of $220,000 for this section.
4) Social Services
Slightly lower costs than budgeted in General Welfare Assistance and Sole Support coupled with lower administration costs due to staff vacancies throughout the year have created a positive variance of $380,000 for the Division.
5) Citizen Services
A change in the Provincial funding formula for Children Services has resulted in a budget reduction and a corresponding municipal cost share reduction of approximately $410,000. In addition, Tom Davies Call Centre is projecting a net under expenditure of $30,000 which results in a total positive variance of $440,000 for this Division.
6) Roads Maintenance
The net over expenditure for Winter Roads maintenance as a result of the increased requirement for salting, sanding, plowing and snow removal is $1.5 Million. This section is weather dependant, therefore, making it challenging to project a potential year end position for this area. In accordance with to the Reserves and Reserve Fund bylaw, any Roads Winter Control over expenditures may be funded from the Roads Winter Control Reserve Fund. The Winter Roads over expenditure has been mitigated slightly by the deliberate curtailing of expenditures in Summer Roads Maintenance resulting in the overall projection of a deficit of $1.3 Million for this Division.
7) Transit and Fleet
This Division is experiencing an overall deficit of about $750,000 which is comprised of $600,000 in Transit and $150,000 in Fleet, as a result of various factors. Firstly, Handi-Transit is projecting an over expenditure of $215,000 to the end of the year which is largely attributed to the increase in number of riders requiring the system. This is offset by a reduction in demand for Transcab services resulting in a projected under expenditure of $35,000. Operations Committee has approved changes to Handi-Transit policies and procedures in an effort to improve the service for customer and reduce costs where possible.
Bus operators are also projecting an over expenditure of $200,000 as a result of ongoing unbudgeted modified work program costs, contractual training requirements for new operator hires, and additional costs related to realignment of staffing levels to achieve approved service levels. The realignment has been phased in and should be accurate in the 2014 budget.
Other items contributing to the variance are snow removal costs for bus shelters of $60,000 and bus parts of $90,000 which is largely due to heavy winter conditions and higher than normal bus repairs. Lastly, an over expenditure of $70,000 in depot building repairs is due to above normal maintenance requirements such as storm receptor vacuuming and HVAC maintenance.
Based on the revenues and expenditures to the end of July 2013, and the departmental projections provided, a year-end deficit of approximately $0.6 Million is projected, mainly as a result of unfavorable winter weather conditions. If a deficit materializes at year-end it would be funded by a draw from the Roads Winter Control Reserve Fund.
However, operating departments are taking measures to mitigate this potential deficit, and curtailing expenditures where possible. Actual year-end results will also vary depending on variables such as weather for November and December, the bond market and final supplementary assessment rolls. If there is a year-end surplus, it would be contributed to the Tax Rate Stabilization Reserve and Capital Financing Reserve Fund-General.